FoodPlacee Passport United States · New York · 80491
Verified Hibbard's Custard
Lewiston, New York, USA
Rating★ 4.6 / 5
CategoryIce Cream Shop
Food Place Passport
Hibbard's Custard in New York
Discover Hibbard's Custard in Lewiston, NY. Explore menu favorites, onsite and takeout options, reviews, and family-friendly atmosphere.
105 Portage Rd, Lewiston, NY 14092, United States
Overview
About This Food Place
Hibbard's Custard is a popular ice cream shop located at 105 Portage Rd, Lewiston, NY. Known for its creamy, homemade custard, the spot offers a variety of rich and delightful flavors including seasonal specials. With a solid reputation and a 4.6-star rating from over 700 reviews, this charming location attracts both locals and visitors seeking a sweet treat in a welcoming atmosphere.
Alongside classic favorites like vanilla ice cream and strawberry milkshakes, Hibbard's serves unique custard combinations such as Coconut Chocolate Almond and Better Brownie Batter. The friendly staff, convenient onsite services, and accessible amenities make it a great stop for a quick dessert or a casual outing.
Gallery
Photos from Hibbard's Custard
Real shots of the food, atmosphere, and signature dishes at this location.
Local favorites
Why People Come Here
This popular ice cream shop draws locals and visitors alike for its creamy custard and welcoming atmosphere.
Homemade Custard & Unique Flavors
Enjoy a variety of rich custards including popular choices like Pumpkin Pie, Butter Pecan, and Better Brownie Batter.
Family-Friendly & Pet-Friendly
Casual picnic tables and a park nearby make this spot ideal for families and pets to relax and enjoy treats together.
Convenient Onsite and Takeout Service
Quick service with options to eat onsite or grab custard and shakes to go fits any schedule.
Highly Rated with Positive Reviews
Boasting a 4.6 rating from over 700 reviews, guests praise the delicious custard and friendly staff.
Accessible Location & Parking Options
Situated on Portage Rd, it offers wheelchair accessible entrances along with free and paid parking nearby.
Quick Visits Perfect for Busy Days
Customers typically spend about 15 minutes here, making it a great spot for a sweet break any time.
Experience
When & How to Enjoy This Place
Ideal for a quick, delightful indulgence with options to savor onsite or take away, Hibbard’s Custard fits moments of all kinds.
Renowned for its creamy texture and inventive flavors, this ice cream shop provides a lively environment with free parking and easy access, making it perfect for brief visits or casual stops during a day out in Lewiston. — FoodPlacee editorial note
Family-Friendly Treat
Enjoy a quick custard break with the entire family. The welcoming atmosphere and safe parking arrangements make it easy for all ages to indulge in favorites like Pumpkin Pie Custard and Medium Butter Pecan Custard.
Takeout Sweetness
Perfect for those on the go, take advantage of takeout options to bring home the delicious handmade custard or refreshing pineapple milkshake for a treat anytime.
Quick Stop During a Day Out
While exploring the Lewiston area, swing by for a quick 15-minute stop to enjoy a refreshing milkshake or a scoop of custard with free parking nearby.
Casual Outdoor Enjoyment
Grab your order and enjoy it outside at picnic tables or nearby park areas to soak up the trending local vibe and fresh air.
Exploring Unique Flavors
Adventurous diners can sample seasonal and specialty flavors like El Dorado Rum or Better Brownie Batter Custard, offering something beyond the classic vanilla and chocolate options.
Dessert lovers Takeout friendly Family-friendly Convenient parking Outdoor seating Unique flavors Card payments accepted
Guest sentiment
What People Feel
A snapshot of what local diners frequently mention about this location.
MA
M Aquino 3 week ago
"Doesn't get better than Hibbard's! Homemade custard hits the spot every time. They serve Perry's along with a variety (usually 4 to 8 various flavors) of homemade custard. Small parking lot but lots of street parking nearby. They have a few picnic tables and there is a nice park across the street. I've never had anything but great custard every visit. Definitely worth the stop!"
MM
Mark Machnica 1 month ago
"This is the best tasting custard I have found in western NY !!! I wish I lived closer, when in the area we have to stop and get some of the best tasting custard..."
KM
K Manson 1 month ago
"MY MOM RAVED ABOUT THIS PLACE FOR WEEKS!!! I got the custard peanut butter and she got the walnut ice cream. It was really tasty. I would highly recommend. Someone actually recommended this place to us from a souvenir shop in Niagara Falls! Worth the trip down."
AL
Aimee Lehner 1 month ago
"As always the custard here is delicious. Never can go wrong with the black raspberry. Others in the group I was with got vanilla and chocolate and enjoyed it a lot. They had special flavors as well that sounded good along with regular ice cream."
FM
Family M 1 month ago
"We make it a point to stop here whenever we’re in the area, and it never disappoints. The custard is some of the creamiest I’ve ever had, and there’s always an exciting new flavor to try. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the pet-friendly atmosphere makes it even better."
J
jarretgnys 2 month ago
"Great selection of alcohol and very friendly staff. Don't forget to stop and get some custard or a milkshake next door. I recommend the Pineapple milkshake."
GL
Gregory Long 3 month ago
"One of the best places for custard ice-cream. Tons of different flavors. Prices are reasonable and service is fast and friendly. Must go to place!"
RK
Renee K 4 month ago
"One of the best custards I’ve ever had! Great flavors. Staff is very friendly. Will be back next time I’m in the area."
Visit info
When to Visit
Weekly hours below — always confirm with the business before holidays or special events.
Today Updating...
Best time to visit
Plan a quick stop for custard during the day, especially when looking for a refreshing treat or a tasty milkshake.
Weekdays for shorter wait times Spend about 15 minutes enjoying your order Takeout perfect for on-the-go cravings Afternoons ideal for family visits
On the map
Where This Food Place Lives
Find your way to Hibbard's Custard in New York .
Address 105 Portage Rd, Lewiston, NY 14092, United States
Phone +1 716-754-4218
Area New York
Call Address copied ✓
Questions answered
Food Place Questions
Find answers to common questions about visiting Hibbard's Custard, a popular ice cream shop in Lewiston, NY.
Payments can be made using debit cards, credit cards, and NFC mobile payments, providing convenient options for all customers.
Seating includes a few picnic tables outside. People usually spend about 15 minutes enjoying their custard in a trending and casual atmosphere.
The location features a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking lot, ensuring ease of access for visitors with mobility needs.
Favorites include Strawberry Milkshake, Double Cheeseburger, Coconut Chocolate Almond Custard, Pineapple Milk Shake, and Pumpkin Pie Custard. Menu items may vary by season.
Free parking is available in both a dedicated lot and on nearby streets. Paid parking lots are also an option for added convenience.
Yes, both onsite dining and takeout services are offered, allowing guests to enjoy custard flavors at home or on the go.
Rated 4.6 out of 5 from over 700 reviews, the shop is praised for its creamy custard, friendly staff, and variety of flavors, though it can get busy at peak times.
Nearby brands
Related food places near Hibbard's Custard
Other casual restaurants and brands diners often visit in New York.
For owners
Own or manage this food place?
Update this page with accurate hours, menu details, photos, and business notes — and reach food lovers searching for places like yours on FoodPlacee.
Menus, prices, hours, services, and availability may change. Please contact the food place directly before visiting or ordering.